Your search results

Live Where a Legend Once Lived

Posted by Bry Locher on December 4, 2025
0 Comments

A truly unique opportunity has arisen in the tranquil Catherine’s Rest neighborhood of St. Croix. We are proud to announce the new listing of the property at 57 Catherine’s Rest, a home that is reported to be the childhood residence of one of the NBA’s greatest: five-time NBA champion, two-time MVP, and San Antonio Spurs icon, Tim Duncan.

A Home with Island Heart and Modern Comfort

This beautiful property isn’t just about its legendary past—it’s a fantastic investment in your island future.

Priced at $454,900, this FHA-Approved, move-in ready home offers a blend of island charm and modern convenience. It features a total of 4 Bedrooms and 3 Bathrooms across 3,519 square feet of living space on an 0.27-acre fully fenced and gated lot.

Key Features of 57 Catherine’s Rest:

  • Income Potential: The structure is perfectly set up as an income generator, featuring a main home (3 BD/2 BA) and an attached, separate apartment (1 BD/1 BA) with its own private entry and independent WAPA meter.
  • Recent Updates: The home has seen significant recent upgrades, including a fixed roof with warranty, split air conditioning in all rooms, new egress windows, and updated stainless steel kitchen appliances in the main unit.
  • Outdoor Amenities: The property boasts a spacious carport, a dedicated workshop ideal for hobbies or storage, and a lush backyard.
  • Prime Location: Enjoy the pastoral views and wonderful breezes from the home, while being just 3 miles from St. Croix’s world-class beaches and mere minutes from the vibrant shopping and dining of Christiansted.

The Boy From St. Croix

Tim Duncan’s journey from the U.S. Virgin Islands to basketball stardom is an inspiring testament to his dedication, his island roots, and the unwavering support of his family.

This incredible story is currently being brought to life in the new documentary, The Boy from St. Croix. The film explores the circumstances and motivations that led the young man from St. Croix to become one of the most decorated and respected players in the history of the sport.

Owning 57 Catherine’s Rest offers a tangible link to this inspiring narrative and the island heritage that shaped a superstar. It’s an opportunity to own a property steeped in history, located in the neighborhood where a legend began to dream.

Watch the Trailer!

To get a glimpse of the story and the island that forged a champion, watch the official trailer for The Boy from St. Croix below:

Don’t miss your chance to own a piece of paradise and a piece of history.

For more information, photos, or to schedule a private showing of this remarkable property at 57 Catherine’s Rest, St. Croix 00820, please contact Jillian Mcmillon today!

View the full listing here

Jillian Mcmillon

340-208-3856

Jillian@ColdwellBankerVI.com

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Compare Listings